The Many Contradictions of Longtime FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover

UnTextbooked | A history podcast for the future

J. Edgar Hoover was a man of contradictions. As the Director of the FBI from 1924 to 1972, he spearheaded homophobic, racist, and anti-communist policies – which arguably shaped half a century of the United States. But he also had an intimate personal relationship with a man and he believed in the role of government to support social conservatism.

Beverly Gage is the author of “G-Man: J. Edgar Hoover and the Making of the American Century”, which won a Pulitzer Prize in Biography. She is a 20th-century American historian at Yale. She also wrote “The Day Wall Street Exploded” which examined the history of terrorism in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Listen to new episodes every Thursday. Follow the show on Spotify, Apple podcasts, Amazon Music or wherever you listen. That way you never miss an episode.

Love the show? Consider writing us a review on your podcast app or telling a friend about the show. This really helps us spread the word.

Visit UnTextbooked.com for learning resources including a glossary of terms.

Show notes:

(0:00) - Who is J. Edgar Hoover?

(1:54) - Intimate Relationship with Clyde Tolson

(3:17) - The Lavender Scare and Government

(6:16) - Early Years and Racist Fraternity

(8:04) - FBI surveilling Civil Rights Movement Leaders

(10:58) - Impact of Anti Communism and McCarthyism

(14:30) - Social Conservatism and Big Government

(16:50) - Process of Writing Biography

(20:39) - An “Incredibly Honest” Paper Trail

(22:31) - Legacy and Impact

(23:55) - Reflection